Creative Cake Supplies

4.9
(131 reviews)
Last updated: May 23, 2025
Website
920-494-3656
Is this your business?*

About The Business

Creative Cake Supplies functions as a retail shop specializing in baking, cake decorating, and candy making supplies. The store offers a comprehensive selection of tools, ingredients, and equipment catering to both hobbyists and professional decorators. It serves as a key resource for individuals looking to create various baked goods and confectionery items.

Beyond its retail operations, Creative Cake Supplies conducts hands-on classes dedicated to baking and cake decorating methods. These classes cover subjects like fundamental cake decorating, working with fondant, decorating cookies, and creating cupcakes. The offerings include structured multi-week courses aimed at developing core skills, alongside individual single-session workshops focusing on particular techniques or projects.

The classes accommodate different experience levels, including those new to baking and decorating, providing participants with direct practical experience in a guided setting. They offer a chance for individuals to gain new abilities, improve existing ones, and express their creativity within the specific areas of baking and decorative confectionery.

Location & Hours

Creative Cake Supplies

1544 W Mason St, Green Bay, 54303

920-494-3656

Get directions
Hours
Mon
10AM-5PM
Tue
10AM-5PM
Wed
10AM-5PM
Thu
10AM-5PM
Fri
10AM-5PM
Sat
10AM-4PM
Sun
Closed

Additional Information

Class types:

Unspecified

Age groups:

Adults

Skill level:

Beginner, All levels

Class themes:

Baking, Pastry, Cake Decorating

Class sizes:

7–15 people

Participation types:

Hands-on

Teacher credentials:

Unspecified

Class types:

Cooking class

Class duration:

Single-sessions, Multi-week series

BYOB allowed?

Not allowed

Creative Cake Supplies Reviews

4.9 131 reviews
Read all reviews on Google
0.0
0.0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Excellent0%
Very good0%
Average0%
Poor0%
Terrible0%

Avoid Gather & Forge – My Experience with Their Private Chef Services

September 12, 2025

I don’t usually write negative reviews, but I wanted to share my experience in case it helps someone else avoid the same mistake.

I hired Gather & Forge well in advance to provide a great private dining experience for guests I had flown in from across the country—two nights in a row. Both nights were a letdown.

The chef showed up 45 minutes to an hour late each night.

The food wasn’t hot. It came out lukewarm or even cool.

The quality of the meal didn’t justify the price. Honestly, I’d say the value was maybe 60% of what we paid.

I gave them plenty of chances to make it right, but they had no interest in doing so. As much as I think Brandon (the chef) worked hard, the overall service just didn’t live up to the cost or the expectations.

Bottom line: Gather & Forge is overpriced, underdelivers, and doesn’t seem to care about customer satisfaction. I really wanted this to be a great experience, but I would never use them again and highly discourage anyone from booking them for private chef services.

Clay

Fabulous venue for events & Italian cooking classes!

August 25, 2025

Our BYOB wine group had an amazing experience Saturday night at A Taste of Milan in the Southside with Chef Sidney and Katie! We learned how to make home made pasta and enjoyed her family recipes handed down from generations! Truly beyond 5 stars and it was a magical evening! Thank you Sidney and Katie

Kim Marie Angiulli